The Layman vs. the Vicar

One of my favorite C.S. Lewis quotes is “Once the layman was anxious to hide the fact that he believed so much less than the vicar; now he tends to hide the fact that he believes so much more.”

I knew Rob Bell left his church in Grandville, Michigan, for southern California, but I didn’t know his Michigan congregation essentially fired him, so I was surprised to see this article in the Christian Post.

I had assumed Bell was at Mars Hill Bible Church so long because the congregation enjoyed having a “celebrity” pastor, in spite of Bell’s sad, hip search for relevance, but that’s not the case. In fact, 3,000 members of the church left after the publication of Bell’s book Love Wins, in which he questions the existence of hell (because it’s just not nice to think about), among other things. Now Bell is in California, looking for ways, the article notes, “to move beyond old-fashioned worship.”

As an aside, isn’t it interesting that all you have to do is call something “old-fashioned” and in some quarters you’ve won the argument? C.S. Lewis had a term for that logical fallacy: “chronological snobbery.”

So God bless the Mars Hill congregation—the laymen. They knew more than the pastor and told him so.

2 Responses to The Layman vs. the Vicar

  1. Nicole says:

    Anyone who believes the Word of God as written in the Bible had to disagree with the essence of Rob Bell and his portrayal of a God with human definition(s) as His spiritual statement. He’s off the mark in so many ways. Lost. Hopefully he’ll find the real Jesus, repent, and receive true salvation.

    This idea of universalism always adheres to a human idea of what love “should” be, not who God defines himself as. They really struggle with sin and hell – not that we all don’t. However, when it finally hits you who God is and who you are: Fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom. He is the origin of all. All definitions of who He is and who we are. No exceptions. His generosity in giving us Jesus is unparallelled and unequaled. But apparently not enough for folks like Rob Bell.

  2. Yikes! Nowdays, public support for heresy is as easy as crying “victim” and slapping on the “old-fashioned” or “intolerant” label. It’s scary how people are being deceived by Satan and leading others into deception. Jesus is coming back soon.

I write mysteries under the name Karin Kaufman and thrillers under the name K.T. Kaufman. When I'm not causing mayhem in the lives of my novels' characters, I enjoy reading, drinking far too much coffee and tea, and taking walks in the foothills of the Colorado Rockies with my two rescue dogs, Sophie and Cooper.






Finalist for a 2011 Grace Award



“Push back against the age as hard as it pushes against you.”

— Flannery O’Connor

“I have avoided becoming stale by putting a little water on the plate, lying on the plate, and having myself refreshed in a toaster oven for 23 minutes once every month.”

— Dean Koontz

“Never ask a barber if you need a haircut.”

— Anonymous

“I am an optimist. It does not seem too much use being anything else.”

— Winston Churchill